Chile Site-Blocking Bill Redundant, Top Court Tells Senate

Written By:

LSB Staff

Published On:

November 19, 2026 1:34 PM

Chile Site-Blocking Bill Redundant, Top Court Tells Senate
  • Chile’s Supreme Court says new articles 238 bis, 238 ter and 238 quáter appear redundant given existing enforcement rules.
  • The court says Article 240 already lets judges undo acts that defy a ruling and carries a prison penalty.
  • It says the telecommunications law, and possibly the casino law, fits better than the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • The bill, Boletín 18.699-07, is in its first Senate stage with no urgency assigned.

SANTIAGO, Chile – A Chile site-blocking bill meant to stop online betting platforms from dodging court orders through new domains appears to repeat powers that judges already hold, the Chilean Supreme Court told the Senate in a report dated Nov. 12.

The court’s full bench took up the bill on Nov. 9 and issued its resolution on Nov. 11, according to Oficio 314-2026, which Court President Gloria Ana Chevesich signed on Nov. 12. The Judicial Branch published the report on Nov. 18.

The bill began as a motion by Senators Esteban Velásquez and Alejandra Sepúlveda, Diario Constitucional reported. The Senate sent it to the court on Sept. 30 under Article 77 of the Constitution.

Courts have already ordered betting platforms’ web addresses blocked, and the bill’s preamble says the platforms keep operating anyway through new domains, subdomains and mirror sites, according to the report. Chile has not yet passed a law licensing online betting operators, unlike the countries with legal sports betting that regulate them.

What The Bill Would Do

The bill is a single article that inserts three provisions into the Code of Civil Procedure. Article 238 bis would require internet providers to block the domains a judge lists within the deadline the judge sets and to file a report proving they did. It would also let a judge extend a block to new domains or mirror sites when technical evidence links them to the blocked platform and lawful services are not affected.

Article 238 ter would let courts demand a report from any provider that does not comply and order coercive measures if the provider fails to report properly. Article 238 quáter would let judges undo new domains or mirror sites that platform operators open to get around a block, widen the original order and apply coercive measures, while respecting due process and not extending criminal liability to anyone the law does not cover.

What The Court Said

The court’s first objection concerns what the text leaves out. The report says neither the bill’s stated purpose nor any of the three articles mentions online betting, even though the preamble names betting platforms’ evasion as the problem. Written for any order blocking any website, the articles “parecen innecesarios y sobreabundantes” in the court’s words, meaning they appear unnecessary and redundant next to current enforcement rules.

The report cites Article 240 of the Code of Civil Procedure as the clearest overlap. Once a ruling has been carried out, that article lets the court order measures to undo whatever is done in violation of it, and it punishes anyone who breaks the order with a prison term, reclusión menor in its medium to maximum degrees. The court said the provision by itself seems to make the new articles pointless.

Articles 235 to 238 already give judges coercive measures matched to the obligation at stake, and the power to compel compliance rests on Article 76 of the Constitution, the report says.

Narrowing the articles to online betting would fix that overlap and raise another problem, the court said. Book I of the Code of Civil Procedure sets rules common to every procedure, and it also applies in criminal proceedings where it does not conflict with the Criminal Procedure Code. A rule on how internet providers and platform operators comply with blocking orders is too specific for that book, according to the report.

The court pointed to the General Telecommunications Law, Law 18.168, as the more suitable place because it governs internet access providers and gives the Transport and Telecommunications Ministry, through its undersecretariat, sanctioning powers. It added that amending Law 19.995, the casino law that created the Superintendencia de Casinos de Juego, could not be ruled out given the motive behind the bill.

The court closed by saying the problem the bill targets “puede estar en otros factores” unrelated to any shortage of court enforcement powers or lack of chances for discussion, as the motion suggests. The report does not say what those factors are. It addresses the bill’s drafting and placement, not whether betting sites should be blocked.

Pending Betting Bill

The report does not mention the Senate’s separate online betting measure, Boletín 14838-03. Amendments to that Chile online betting bill cleared the Senate Economy Committee 3-1, with one abstention, on Nov. 9, the day the court met. The amendments would oblige internet providers to cut access to banned platforms and let courts block illegal ones permanently, T13 reported, placing those duties in gambling legislation and not the Code of Civil Procedure.

The government’s competing plan would license platforms instead, the approach U.S. states use for legal sports betting.

Advertising Disclosure

In order to provide you with the best independent sports betting news and content LegalSportsBetting.com may receive a commission from partners when you make a purchase through a link on our site.

Ben Fiore

LSB Staff

The official account representing the staff of LegalSportsBetting. Posts and updates shared here reflect the work of our newsroom as a whole rather than any single writer or editor.