- Judge Valerie Caproni found a trade group likely to establish that the CFTC lacks authority to open stock perps to retail investors.
- Her Nov. 3 order refused a restraining order, finding the group’s harm claims conjectural, so approvals for three exchanges stand.
- Caproni gave the CFTC until Friday, Nov. 6, to oppose a preliminary injunction and the group until Tuesday, Nov. 10, to reply.
- The order treats the contracts as probable swaps, which belong to the SEC rather than the CFTC.
NEW YORK – The Commodity Futures Trading Commission must respond Friday to a request to block its approval of stock perps, perpetual futures on individual stocks, after a judge found a trade group likely to establish that the agency lacks authority to let retail investors trade them.
The three-page order, signed Nov. 3 by U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni of the Southern District of New York, is docket entry 11 in Capital Markets Alliance Association v. Commodity Futures Trading Commission, No. 1:26-cv-09608. It rejects the group’s bid to stay the CFTC’s approvals of applications from KalshiEX, Coinbase Derivatives and Bitnomial Exchange to list perpetual derivatives on single stocks.
A security future, the order reasons, requires a “sale for future delivery of a single security,” and a perpetual contract by definition carries no such obligation, so the contracts “do not appear to satisfy the definition of a ‘security future.'” What they do appear to match is the statutory definition of a swap, and swaps of that kind, the order says, answer to the Securities and Exchange Commission rather than the CFTC.
On the two remaining factors the order sides with the group, finding the balance of equities tips its way and relief serves the public, because the CFTC’s actions “seem to represent a major disruption to the equities market,” Caproni wrote. Irreparable harm was the factor that sank the motion. The three declarations the group filed are “conjectural” about what members would lose, the order says, and dwell on events that could occur rather than harm members are likely to suffer.
Under the four-part test the order applies, that leaves the group ahead on three factors, with imminent harm the only point between it and the relief it seeks.
Adam Ford, the group’s secretary, listed Cboe Global Markets, Citadel Securities and Healthy Markets Association as members in a declaration attached to the emergency motion. In the complaint, the plaintiff is a nonprofit trade association headquartered in New York that goes by the Alliance.
The suit, against the CFTC and Chairman Michael Selig, seeks vacatur of the approvals, a declaration that single-stock perpetuals are security-based swaps and an injunction against giving the approvals effect. Retail investors, the complaint argues, may trade security-based swaps only on SEC-registered national securities exchanges, and the CFTC itself had long treated perpetual derivatives as swaps.
The three applications date from Sept. 18, according to the complaint, which says the CFTC issued no reasoned order and instead let the 45-day clock expire Nov. 2, at which point Commission Regulation 40.3 deemed the filings approved. Selig’s statement the next day described the products as security futures products that fall under both the Commodity Exchange Act and federal securities laws, with trading open on CFTC-registered exchanges.
The complaint calls the stock approvals the latest in a series of CFTC decisions that label perpetual contracts futures and not swaps. It cites a May approval of a Kalshi bitcoin perpetual that the Chicago Mercantile Exchange is challenging in federal court in Washington.
The Swap Question
The CFTC has told federal courts that sports and other event contracts are swaps, a category the Commodity Exchange Act places under its exclusive jurisdiction when traded on designated contract markets. The agency made that argument when it sued Utah on Oct. 26, and the complaint rests on subparagraphs (i), (ii) and (iv) of the swap definition in 7 U.S.C. § 1a(47)(A). Caproni’s order cites subparagraph (iii) of the same definition and does not mention event contracts.
The CFTC says it has started legal proceedings against nine other states, and several of them, including Arizona, Illinois and New York, license legal sports betting. The Alliance’s case concerns stock contracts, and the question the order addresses is whether they count as security futures inside the CFTC’s authority or as swaps in the SEC’s.
Briefing Schedule
Two filings remain before the injunction question is ripe. The CFTC’s opposition comes first, on Friday, Nov. 6. The Alliance then has until Tuesday, Nov. 10, to answer it. Caproni’s order adds that the schedule is “subject to change by the assigned District Court Judge.”
