Six Teams Chase Two Spots As MLB Wild Card Race Tightens

Written By:

Lorcan Palaca

Published On:

September 14, 2026 11:14 AM

Six Teams Chase Two Spots As MLB Wild Card Race Tightens
  • Cleveland leads Toronto by one game, Texas by two and Baltimore by four for the AL’s last wild card berth.
  • Philadelphia and Chicago, both 83-67, hold the NL’s top two wild card seeds with San Diego 1.5 games back.
  • Arizona needs to erase a 2.5-game deficit to San Diego to steal the NL’s final berth.
  • Baltimore is priced at +4000 to reach the playoffs, the longest shot left in either race.

CLEVELAND – The Cleveland Guardians hold the American League’s last playoff berth by one game over the Toronto Blue Jays with 12 left on the schedule. The National League race is just as unsettled. The Philadelphia Phillies and Chicago Cubs sit tied at the top of that board, and San Diego’s grip on the last NL berth is 2 1/2 games over Arizona.

Cleveland’s Cushion Comes Down To One Game

The Guardians are 76-74 and sit alone in the American League’s third wild card slot, with Toronto (75-75) one game back, the Texas Rangers (74-76) two back and the Baltimore Orioles (72-78) four back in the wild card standings. Cleveland is -220 to make the playoffs and Toronto is next closest at +145, prices that track how bunched the field is, with all three chasers within four games of the cutoff line and 12 to play.

Cleveland is a -150 moneyline favorite at home Monday against the Chicago White Sox, and Toronto is -130 at home against Detroit, meaning the two teams separated by one game for the final AL spot are each favored to hold serve the same night. Baltimore’s +4000 reflects the size of the climb still ahead, with four games and three teams to pass in the final 12.

Six teams are still fighting over the two unsettled spots, and the legal MLB betting board prices all six to reach the postseason.

TeamOdds
Cleveland Guardians-220
Toronto Blue Jays+145
Texas Rangers+190
Baltimore Orioles+4000
San Diego Padres-525
Arizona Diamondbacks+275

Yankees And Red Sox Aren’t Sweating The Number

New York, at 86-63, owns the AL’s top wild card seed with a 10 1/2-game cushion on the cut line, and Boston, at 82-68, is six clear – neither is part of the scrum below. Neither Boston nor New York carries a playoff number at all anymore on legal sports betting sites, a sign books have already treated both outcomes as settled with two weeks to go. New York is a -139 road favorite Monday at Minnesota.

Phillies And Cubs Share The NL’s Top Two Spots

At 83-67 apiece, the Phillies and Cubs occupy the NL’s first two seeds with a 1.5-game cushion on San Diego. Philadelphia’s playoff price sits at -8000 and Chicago’s has come off the board entirely, treatment that reads as a formality even though the standings still show a flat tie between them. Chicago hosts NL East-leading Atlanta as a -138 home favorite Monday.

San Diego Holds, Arizona Presses

San Diego, at 81-68, has the NL’s No. 3 seed to itself, and Arizona, at 79-71, must make up 2.5 games in its final 12 to take it. San Diego is -525 to make the field, a number that reflects a team defending position rather than chasing it, while Arizona’s +275 leaves room for exactly the gap still in front of it. Both teams are favored Monday, San Diego at -190 on the road against last-place Colorado and Arizona at -136 at home against Miami.

The schedule runs out Sept. 27, and each contender gets 12 or 13 more chances to protect its spot or close the gap on it.

Advertising Disclosure

In order to provide you with the best independent sports betting news and content LegalSportsBetting.com may receive a commission from partners when you make a purchase through a link on our site.

Ben Fiore

Lorcan Palaca

Lorcan covers the legal sports betting industry with a focus on sports news, analysis, and betting-related storylines. As a student at Florida State University, he researches data to present accurate content for bettors and sports fans. Lorcan loves to identify emerging trends, player and team developments, and the changing betting markets. Outside of writing, he can often be found supporting Florida State athletics in person.