Adam Schiff Says 12 State Suits Break Selig’s Court Pledge

Written By:

LSB Staff

Published On:

November 20, 2026 4:20 PM

Schiff Says 12 State Suits Break Selig's Court Pledge
  • Michael Selig broke his confirmation pledge to follow the courts, Adam Schiff said, and his office’s release cites CFTC lawsuits against 12 states.
  • The CFTC’s Nov. 13 release on Louisiana counts it as the 12th state the commission has sued.
  • At his 2025 confirmation hearing, Selig said court rulings would guide him and he held no preset view of sports contracts.
  • Schiff and eight colleagues want Selig’s geofencing interpretation rescinded or suspended, and their Nov. 16 letter seeks an answer by Nov. 23.

WASHINGTON – Sen. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., told the Senate Agriculture Committee on Nov. 17 that Commodity Futures Trading Commission Chairman Michael Selig broke his confirmation-hearing promise to abide by court rulings about prediction markets, and Schiff’s office set Selig’s court pledge against CFTC lawsuits filed against 12 states.

Selig did not testify. The hearing took up a pair of commissioner nominations, those of Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland, and Schiff said the commission now has a single member the Senate has confirmed. Schiff’s office posted video and a transcript of his remarks in a release dated Nov. 18, which says Selig has made no appearance before the committee since the Senate confirmed him. The 12-state figure is in that release, not in the transcript of his remarks.

What Schiff Told The Committee

Schiff told the panel he did not know whether Selig “was just lying to us” or had “some kind of an epiphany” once confirmed. “I don’t know that I’ve ever been so blatantly deceived by a nominee before,” he said. He said Selig had “filed briefs to tell the courts what to do” and, after courts ruled against prediction markets, “basically told companies to ignore the courts.”

Selig’s pledge is in the transcript of his Nov. 19, 2025, confirmation hearing. Schiff’s question that day was whether picking a football game’s winner through an event contract amounts to gambling. Selig said, “I will follow what the courts say.” Selig also said he would come to the issue “with a blank slate and look to the courts.”

Schiff’s argument has a written history. A Feb. 13 letter led by Schiff and signed by 23 Senate Democrats cited Selig’s “blank slate” testimony and urged the agency to stay out of pending court fights over sports, war and other barred event contracts.

How The CFTC Counts Its Suits

The CFTC’s Nov. 13 release on Louisiana calls the state the 12th the commission has taken to court over its claim to sole authority across derivatives markets, and counts friend-of-the-court briefs in four federal appeals courts and one state high court. The CFTC announced its 11th suit, against Arkansas, the same day. The first three, against Arizona, Connecticut and Illinois, came April 2, which makes 12 suits in a little over seven months.

The two newest suits answered state action. The CFTC sued one day after Louisiana’s order shut down more than 30 companies Nov. 12, and its release says the defendants got no notice or chance to be heard. The Arkansas suit targets a state civil case against Kalshi. Selig said in the Louisiana release that the commission’s lawsuit “seeks to maintain the status quo while the federal courts decide this issue in an orderly manner.”

In its April 24 release on New York, the CFTC said it wants a federal court to rule that it alone may regulate event contracts and to block New York from applying state laws the agency calls preempted to CFTC-registered exchanges. A ruling for the CFTC on that theory would leave event contracts on those exchanges outside the licensing rules that govern legal sports betting in the state.

Anonick’s Answer

Anonick got the football question Selig had faced a year earlier. Schiff asked if a wager placed through a prediction market on Thursday’s Colts-Texans game counts as sports betting. Anonick, who said he spoke for no one else, answered that federal courts have split and the question is complex as a matter of law.

Pressed to choose between yielding to the courts and taking the current chairman’s course, Anonick pointed to the Supreme Court. If confirmed, he said, he would back the agency abiding by a ruling from the justices on the issue, whichever way it goes. He said he had not settled on a position and would first hear from the CFTC’s general counsel’s office, outside lawyers, tribes, states and others with a stake.

Nov. 23 Deadline

The CFTC’s Nov. 5 interpretation, whose release sets a 30-day clock on location limits and does not mention court orders, drew a Nov. 9 charge from Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto, D-Nev., that Selig is urging court defiance.

The Nov. 16 letter to Selig, signed by Schiff and eight Democratic colleagues, among them Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., the committee’s ranking member, says the interpretation runs against court orders now in force in three states, Michigan, Nevada and Washington, as well as on two California tribes’ land.

It asks Selig to rescind his reading of the rule or suspend it until the court cases conclude, and asks the commission to keep every record and message on the subject dating to Jan. 1, 2025. The senators set Nov. 23 for a reply that confirms in writing the records are being kept.

Advertising Disclosure

In order to provide you with the best independent sports betting news and content LegalSportsBetting.com may receive a commission from partners when you make a purchase through a link on our site.

Ben Fiore

LSB Staff

The official account representing the staff of LegalSportsBetting. Posts and updates shared here reflect the work of our newsroom as a whole rather than any single writer or editor.