Aaron Judge, Cal Raleigh Neck & Neck In AL MVP Odds

Written By:

Sam Profeta

Published On:

September 22, 2025 3:39 PM

Aaron Judge, Cal Raleigh Neck & Neck In AL MVP Odds
  • Aaron Judge has -130 odds to win the American League MVP.
  • There are +100 odds for Cal Raleigh to win the AL MVP.

NEW YORK – We are in the final week of the MLB regular season, and the American League MVP is currently knotted in a two man race between Aaron Judge and Cal Raleigh.

As for where the odds currently sit, legal sports betting sites are sticking with Aaron Judge with the shortest odds. However, this is the closest that Raleigh’s odds have been to Judge all season. This also marks the closest to even odds that Judge has been since having plus money odds back on March 26.

American League MVP Odds

  • Aaron Judge -130
  • Cal Raleigh +100

Odds Journey + A Case For Both

It has been Aaron Judge’s MVP to lose all season long based on the MLB betting odds. He has had the shortest odds all season long and officially made the jump to under +100 odds back in April after moving from +300 down to -170.

Judge’s odds were most expensive in early June when they were listed at -13000. Since then, they have come up and landed at the -130 that they are currently being offered at.

Looking at Raleigh, he was a major underdog to start the season at +8000 odds and even saw his odds climb to over +11000 at one point in mid-April. Since then, they have significantly dropped and have been offered at under +500 since mid-July.

As far as the numbers go, holding up Judge’s favored odds are his batting average of .326 and OPS at 1.123, which are both the highest in the MLB this season. He is also second in total runs (130), and eighth in both hits (170) and RBI (105).

The case for Raleigh comes with his league leading home run total (58) and third highest RBI (121) and OPS (.949) totals. However, Judge does have a major advantage in batting average and hits, where Raleigh isn’t even in the top-50 in the league.

Advertising Disclosure

In order to provide you with the best independent sports betting news and content LegalSportsBetting.com may receive a commission from partners when you make a purchase through a link on our site.

Ben Fiore

Sam Profeta

Samuel has been writing professionally for 4 years. He comes from a sports writing background where he enjoys writing mostly about basketball and football both professional and collegiate. He is a recent graduate of Florida State University where he majored in Editing, Writing and Media with a minor in Communications. During his free time, you can find him watching or playing sports as well as playing videogames and listening to music.